Do Not Call
This article explains the fundamental differences between market-cap weighted and price-weighted indices, including their structure, calculation methods, advantages, limitations, and their implications for investors and markets.
Stock market indices are essential tools for investors, helping track the performance of a group of stocks that represent either a specific market segment or the entire market. They act as benchmarks for measuring economic trends and portfolio performance.
Understanding how these indices are constructed is crucial to interpreting their movements accurately. Two of the most common weighting methods are market-cap weighted and price-weighted indices.
This article explains how these indices work and their implications for interpreting market movements.
A market-cap weighted index assigns weights to its constituent stocks based on their market capitalisation.
Market capitalisation is the total value of a company’s shares available in the market, calculated as:
Market Capitalisation = Number of Shares Outstanding × Current Share Price
In this approach:
Companies with larger market values have a greater impact on the index.
Smaller companies carry less influence on index movements.
This method is widely used because it reflects the true economic size of companies in the market. Next, let’s look at some well-known examples.
Some of the most widely followed market-cap weighted indices include:
Nifty 50 (NSE, India): Tracks the major 50 companies by market cap on the National Stock Exchange.
S&P 500 (USA): Comprises 500 large-cap US stocks weighted by market cap.
Sensex (BSE, India): A benchmark index of 30 large-cap companies on the Bombay Stock Exchange.
The value of a market-cap weighted index is determined by the combined market capitalisation of its constituent stocks.
Formula (Simplified):
Index Level = (Sum of Market Capitalisations of All Stocks) ÷ Divisor
Market Capitalisation = Number of Shares Outstanding × Share Price
Divisor is a normalising factor used to:
Maintain index continuity over time
Adjust for corporate actions like stock splits, dividends, or changes in the constituent list
This ensures that the index reflects real market movements, not distortions from technical adjustments.
Market-cap weighted indices are widely used around the world. Like any method, they come with both strengths and limitations.
Represents economic size: Reflects the true weight of companies in the market.
Dynamic adjustment: Weights automatically change as stock prices move.
Benchmark standard: Commonly used for passive investing and index funds.
Concentration risk: Can become dominated by a few very large companies.
Valuation bias: May overweight stocks that are overvalued, affecting overall index performance.
Next, let’s explore price-weighted indices and compare them to market-cap weighted indices.
In a price-weighted index, the influence of each stock depends on its share price, not its overall market capitalisation. This means that higher-priced stocks carry more weight, even if the company itself is smaller in size.
Formula:
Index Value = (Sum of Prices of Constituent Stocks) ÷ Divisor
The divisor is a scaling factor used to keep the index consistent over time.
It is adjusted to account for corporate actions such as stock splits, dividends, or changes in the index composition.
Example:
If Stock A is priced at ₹5,000 and Stock B is priced at ₹500, Stock A will have ten times more impact on the index level, even if both companies have the same market capitalisation.
Price-weighted indices are simple to calculate but can sometimes give a skewed picture of the market.
Price-weighted indices have their own strengths and weaknesses. While they are easy to understand, they may not always give the most accurate reflection of the market.
Simplicity: Easy to calculate and track, making them accessible for beginners.
Direct impact: Stock price changes immediately affect the index level.
Price dominance: Heavily influenced by high-priced stocks, even if the company is small.
Distortion from stock splits: Splits require divisor adjustments and can skew index weightings.
Limited accuracy: Does not truly represent company size or overall market value.
These characteristics highlight why price-weighted indices are less commonly used today compared to market-cap weighted indices.
The table below summarises key differences between the two types of indices, comparing their weighting basis, sensitivity, impact of stock splits, and examples:
| Feature | Market-Cap Weighted Index | Price-Weighted Index |
|---|---|---|
Weighting Basis |
Market Capitalisation |
Stock Price |
Influence |
Larger companies have more impact |
Higher priced stocks have more impact |
Sensitivity |
Sensitive to market value changes |
Sensitive to stock price changes |
Effect of Stock Splits |
Minimal effect; divisor adjusted |
Significant effect; divisor adjusted |
Market Representation |
More accurate representation of company size |
May misrepresent company size |
Examples |
Nifty 50, S&P 500, Sensex |
Dow Jones Industrial Average, Nikkei 225 |
Understanding these differences helps investors interpret index performance and the market's underlying dynamics.
The choice of index weighting has a direct impact on investors and the products they use.
Most index funds and ETFs track market-cap weighted indices, as these represent the overall market size.
Price-weighted indices are rarely used as a base for investment products due to their limited accuracy.
Market-cap weighted indices create higher exposure to large-cap companies, reducing representation of mid and small caps.
Price-weighted indices may give excessive weight to high-priced stocks, which may not align with company fundamentals.
Market-cap weighted indices generally provide a more accurate picture of the market.
Price-weighted indices can be more volatile due to the larger impact of fluctuations in a few high-priced stocks.
These differences explain why market-cap weighted indices are commonly used in modern investment products.
Several factors determine whether an index uses market-cap weighting or price weighting, ranging from historical practices to investor needs.
Historical context: Price-weighted indices are older and were widely used in the early stages of index creation. Market-cap weighting later emerged to provide a representation more closely aligned with company size and market value.
Regulatory considerations: Transparency and investor protection make market-cap based indices more relevant today.
Market preferences: Both institutional and retail investors generally prefer indices that reflect true market size and economic realities.
Calculation complexity: Price-weighted indices are simpler to compute but need frequent divisor adjustments for stock splits or corporate actions.
These factors explain why market-cap weighted indices dominate modern markets, while price-weighted indices are now mostly of historical or academic interest.
Here are some common misconceptions explained:
Index weighting methods affect how changes in constituent stocks influence the index but do not alone determine investment returns.
Stock splits heavily affect price-weighted indices but are neutralised through divisor adjustments.
Market-cap weighted indices may seem biased toward large companies but offer a more realistic market picture.
Understanding the difference between market-cap weighted and price-weighted indices helps interpret stock market movements more accurately. Market-cap weighted indices offer a representation aligned with company size, while price-weighted indices focus on stock prices. Each method has advantages and limitations, influencing their suitability for different investment purposes.
This content is for informational purposes only and the same should not be construed as investment advice. Bajaj Finserv Direct Limited shall not be liable or responsible for any investment decision that you may take based on this content.
A market-cap weighted index weights constituent stocks by their total market capitalisation, giving more influence to larger companies.
It sums the prices of all constituent stocks and divides by a divisor adjusted for stock splits and similar events.
Because weighting is based on stock price, splits affect prices directly, requiring divisor adjustments; market-cap indices weight by total value, so splits have less direct impact.
Market-cap weighted indices are more widely used because they represent company size and market value more proportionately, making them a preferred choice for many index providers and exchanges.
Yes, weighting affects index composition, concentration, and sensitivity to stock movements, influencing risk and return profiles.
The S&P 500 is primarily a market-cap weighted index, but there is also an equal-weighted version where each stock has the same weight.
Market cap reflects the true economic size of a company, while price alone does not indicate value. For example, a company with a ₹500 share price but only 1 Lakh shares is smaller than one with a ₹50 share price and 1 Crore shares.
Price-weighted indices are simple to calculate and easy to understand, making them useful for quick analysis and historical comparisons, such as with the Dow Jones Industrial Average.While price-weighted indices are simple to track, their use is now limited, and they may not always represent the true size of a company’s impact on the market.
Because they give more weight to high-priced stocks regardless of company size, they can overstate the impact of small firms with high share prices, misrepresenting overall market performance.
