BAJAJ FINSERV DIRECT LIMITED

Stocks Insights

Short Selling vs. Put Options: What’s the Difference

Nupur Wankhede Posted on October 03, 2025

When investors expect a stock’s price to decline, two strategies often come to mind: short selling and buying put options. Both are bearish, but they differ significantly in mechanics, risks, and capital requirements.

What Is Short Selling

Short selling involves borrowing shares from a broker and selling them in the market, hoping to buy them back later at a lower price. If the stock drops, the investor profits from the price difference.

However, it carries unlimited loss potential, since a stock’s price can rise indefinitely. It also requires a margin account, and investors face margin calls if prices move unfavorably.

What Is a Put Option

A put option gives the holder the right to sell an underlying asset at a specific strike price before the option expires. The risk is limited to the premium paid, making it safer than short selling.

Put options are commonly used by investors for hedging or speculative purposes, especially during uncertain or bearish market phases.

Key Differences Between Short Selling and Put Options

Short selling and put options may seem similar at first glance, but the mechanics and risks are quite distinct:

Feature	Short Selling	Put Option
Risk	Unlimited	Limited to premium paid
Capital Requirement	High (margin needed)	Lower (premium only)
Expiration	No expiration	Has expiry date
Profit Potential	High, but risky	Defined by strike and premium
Execution Complexity	Requires share borrowing	Can be executed via options account
Typical Users	Advanced traders with margin access	Retail investors, hedgers

Pros and Cons of Each Strategy

Here’s how the benefits and limitations of short selling and put options compare:

Strategy	Pros	Cons
Short Selling	Potentially higher profit, no time decay	Unlimited loss, requires margin, harder execution
Put Options	Limited risk, no borrowing needed, lower capital	Time decay, limited lifespan, premium cost

When to Consider Short Selling vs. Put Options

Here’s a quick guide on when each approach is commonly used:

Short selling: Generally used by institutional traders with margin access in high-volume stocks, while put options are more commonly accessed by retail participants for limited-risk exposure.
Put Options: Often used by retail investors looking for limited risk exposure or a hedge against downside movement.

Examples to Illustrate the Difference

Consider the following example:

Stock Price: ₹100

Short Seller sells at ₹100 → stock falls to ₹80 → profit = ₹20 per share
Put Buyer buys ₹100 strike put for ₹5 → stock falls to ₹80 → profit = ₹15 (₹20 gain – ₹5 premium)

If stock rises to ₹120:

Short Seller loses ₹20
Put Buyer loses only ₹5 (premium)

Note: This is a simplified example for illustration only. Actual outcomes may differ due to transaction costs, liquidity, and market conditions.

Regulatory and Practical Considerations

Here’s how regulations and practice affect each approach:

Short Selling: Subject to margin requirements, borrow fees, and restrictions (especially during market volatility).
Put Options: Easier to access, especially via options-enabled retail accounts, but require understanding of option greeks, expiry effects, and pricing models.

Conclusion

Both short selling and put options are designed to profit from falling markets, but they cater to different risk profiles. Short selling and put options cater to different profiles, short selling typically involves advanced margin trading and higher risk, while put options provide defined risk and structured exposure. Each approach carries unique risks and considerations. The choice ultimately depends on capital availability, risk tolerance, and market timing.

Disclaimer

This content is for informational purposes only and the same should not be construed as investment advice. Bajaj Finserv Direct Limited shall not be liable or responsible for any investment decision that you may take based on this content.

FAQs on Short Selling vs. Put Options

Which strategy is riskier: short selling or buying puts?

Short selling is riskier because losses can be unlimited if the stock price keeps rising, while buying put options limits losses to the premium paid.

Do I need a margin account to short sell or buy puts?

Short selling typically requires a margin account due to share borrowing. Put options, on the other hand, are generally accessed through options-enabled accounts, subject to brokerage terms and regulations.

Which strategy is better for retail investors?

Put options are commonly used by retail investors because they carry limited risk compared to short selling, though both strategies involve significant considerations.

How do profits differ between the two strategies?

Short selling offers potentially higher profits if the stock price falls significantly, but also comes with unlimited downside risk. Put options provide limited profit potential, but the risk is capped at the premium paid.

Can both strategies be used for hedging?

Both short selling and buying puts can be used for hedging, but put options are more commonly used because they provide cost-effective downside protection without unlimited risk.

Are there hidden costs in short selling?

Yes, short selling involves hidden costs such as stock borrow fees, margin interest, and potential compliance restrictions, which can reduce overall profitability.

Hi! I’m Nupur Wankhede

BSE Insitute Alumni

With a Postgraduate degree in Global Financial Markets from the Bombay Stock Exchange Institute, Nupur has over 8 years of experience in the financial markets, specializing in investments, stock market operations, and project management. She has contributed to process improvements, cross-functional initiatives & content development across investment products. She bridges investment strategy with execution, blending content insight, operational efficiency, and collaborative execution to deliver impactful outcomes.

Read More

Most Viewed

Stocks Insights What Is a Variable Repo Rate?

4 Min Read | Posted on 03 Oct

Stocks Insights What is Written Down Value (WDV)?

2 Min Read | Posted on 03 Oct

Stocks Insights SEBI Regulations on Algorithmic Trading in India

5 Min Read | Posted on 03 Oct

Stocks Insights Short Selling vs. Put Options: What’s the Difference

2 Min Read | Posted on 03 Oct

Home

Steal Deals

CIBIL Score

Accounts

Explore